Most-LovedSweet Potato Swirl
from $6.99
Amityville, NY · Est. 2011Freshly Baked
Happiness
Since 2011.
Family-owned, hand-swirled gourmet cheesecakes baked fresh on Long Island. Three generations of recipes — and zero nuts in the kitchen.
5Yelp & Google
Featured by Nicki Minaj
starting at
$6.99
per treat
Our story
A family obsession with the perfect treat.
Since 2011, Dessert First has been Long Island's quiet dessert destination — a family-run shop in Amityville where every cheesecake is baked, swirled, and finished by hand. Featured by Nicki Minaj. Adored by Yelp. Trusted by your most particular aunt.
In the kitchen
Baked this morning
Family recipes
Three generations of technique, never written down, only handed down.
Made fresh, daily
Small batches, every morning. Nothing sits, nothing waits.
100% nut-free kitchen
So everyone at your table can enjoy the same treat.
Say hi to
Dot, our resident sweet-talker.
She's been with the shop since the very first oven preheat. Give her a tap — she's got opinions, fun facts, and at least one strong recommendation.
Our Treats
Indulge in our signature cheesecakes.
Hand-swirled and baked fresh daily. Available as a single, mini, or 9-inch whole.
Most-Loved
Customer FavoriteBanana Puddin'
from $6.99
Fresh FruitStrawberry Swirl
from $6.99
Winter FavoriteHot Chocolate
from $6.99
BestsellerCookies & Cream
from $6.99
Cult FavoriteMint Chocolate
from $6.99
SeasonalPumpkin Spice
from $6.99
Personal SizeChocolate Drizzle Bite
from $6.99
Plus seasonal swirls: Blueberry, Peach, Mango, Salted Caramel, Apple Cinnamon, Coconut & more.
See the Full MenuMenu & Pricing
Pick your size.
Order ahead — fresh batches sell out daily.
Single
Personal treat
$6.99
Mini
Individual cheesecake
$9.99
9" Whole
Feeds 12–14 people
$49.99
Premium 9": Red Velvet $62.99 · Cookies & Cream $52.99
Cheesecake Bites (6 pcs)
$19.99Banana Pudding
$7.99Classic
- Plain Vanilla
- Strawberry Swirl
- Blueberry Swirl
- Red Velvet
- Brownie Bottom
- Cookies & Cream
Seasonal
- Apple Cinnamon
- Pumpkin Spice
- Hot Chocolate
- Sweet Potato Swirl
- Salted Caramel
Tropical
- Banana Puddin'
- Peach Swirl
- Mango Swirl
- Banana Strawberry
- Coconut
- Mint
Sugar-free flavors: Plain Vanilla, Strawberry Swirl, Apple Cinnamon, Blueberry Swirl · Gluten-free on request · Always 100% nut-free.
Custom orders require 2 days advance notice.
What Customers Say
Long Island has been talking.
"It feels like they read bedtime stories and tuck the cheesecakes in at night. That's how delightful and dreamy each bite is."
"Best cheesecake on all of Long Island. Everything is made in-house and the pricing is extremely reasonable."
"The sweet potato cheesecake is on another level. The best cheesecake I have ever had."
"By far the best cheesecake I've ever had. I worked in Brooklyn for years and passed Juniors every day — this is much better."
"Dare I say the best cheesecake on Long Island? I love that I get to support a genuinely amazing small business."
"Worth every single penny. Nothing short of amazing. The owners are so pleasant and the place is spotless."
5★ on Yelp & GoogleFeatured by Nicki Minaj13+ Years on Long Island
Visit
Stop by the shop.
Address
201 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701
Phone
(702) 545-6802
thecheesecakespot@gmail.com
Hours
- Mon & Sun: Closed
- Tue: 9am – 5:30pm
- Wed: 9am – 6pm
- Thu – Sat: 9am – 7pm
Special services
Custom ordersParty cateringGluten-freeSugar-free
Custom orders require 2 days advance notice.
Call or text
Tell us your flavor, size, and pickup time.
We bake fresh
Your cheesecake is made from scratch the same day.
Pick up
201 Broadway, Amityville. Come hungry.
From the shop
Straight from the oven.